Home / Field Manual / How to Vet an AEO Agency

How to vet an AEO agency: ask for proof first.

What to look for when you need an AI visibility audit and an agency says it does answer engine optimization. Start with proof, then ask 8 more questions.

9 min read By Lindsay Smith St. Petersburg, FL Last updated November 17, 2026

Ask any AEO agency for dated proof from a real client: the AI answers before the work, the AI answers after, and the business numbers that changed. A credible agency can show you which questions it tested, on which platforms, and what moved. If they can't show proof, keep looking.

What an AI visibility audit is

An AI visibility audit checks whether tools like ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Perplexity mention your business when a customer asks a question you should own. It also checks what they say about you when they do.

AI tools can give 2 different answers to the same question asked twice in a row, so one run only tells you what happened that one time. A useful audit tracks the trend across weeks, with dates.

Ask for proof before anything else

AEO is new enough that almost anyone can claim to do it. Very few can show a client they moved, with dates and screenshots. Make proof your first question on any agency call.

Real proof has 4 parts:

  1. A starting point. What AI tools said, or didn't say, before the work.
  2. Dated AI answers after the work. The exact question, the platform, the date, and the page that got cited.
  3. Business numbers. Visits from AI tools and what those visitors did, pulled from analytics.
  4. A name you can check. A real business whose website you can visit yourself.

What that proof looks like: Sapia's Barbershop

Here's one of mine. I built a new site for Sapia's Barbershop in Clearwater, Florida, which launched May 1, 2026. It replaced about 4 template pages with 13 custom ones, including pages for special needs haircuts and specific trending cuts.

Sapia's Barbershop, Clearwater, FL

What AI tools said

  • September 10, 2026: Sapia's was the top pick for special-needs barbershop searches in Tampa Bay on ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Perplexity. Google's AI Overview cited the Special Needs Haircuts page, which was also the number 1 organic result.
  • September 17, 2026: ChatGPT cited the matching Sapia's page for broccoli, anime-inspired, warrior and Viking haircut questions, and for sensory-issues and female-client questions.
  • October 8, 2026: Google's AI Overview for "sapias barbershop reviews" cited a barber profile page and Tina Sapia's About page.

What the analytics showed (GA4, May 1 to October 31, 2026)

  • Visits from AI tools went from 0 at launch to 45 in October.
  • AI visits grew 5x from June to October.
  • AI tools sent about 1 in 11 visitors in October, up from 1 in 40 in June.
  • In October, 42% of AI-tool visits included a booking or call tap. Google visits came in at 43% and direct visits at 23%.

The last number matters most to a business owner. People who found Sapia's through ChatGPT booked at about the same rate as people who found it on Google, and almost twice the rate of direct visitors.

That's the standard to hold any agency to, including me. Read the full Sapia's case study.

What a good AI visibility audit covers

I use 4 questions, in this order:

  1. Can they find you? Do AI tools mention you for the questions your customers ask?
  2. Do they understand you? Do they describe what you do, where, and for whom correctly?
  3. Do they trust you? Do your reviews, listings and website all tell the same story?
  4. Will they choose you? When you show up next to competitors, is there a clear reason to pick you?

A customer can't trust a business they don't understand, and they can't understand one they never found. Plenty of audits measure the first question and stop there. Ask any agency how their audit covers all 4.

8 more questions to ask an AEO agency before you sign

01Which questions will you test, and where do they come from?

Good answer: real buyer questions for your service and city, such as "special needs barbershop in Tampa Bay." Your business name typed into ChatGPT is a different test. It's useful for checking accuracy and tells you nothing about whether new customers can find you. Ask for the full query list before work starts.

02Which AI platforms are in the test?

At minimum: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Perplexity. Each one pulls from different places. Google AI Overviews leans heavily on your Google Business Profile and reviews. Perplexity searches the web live on every query and shows numbered sources. An audit that checks one platform tells you about one platform.

03Can I see the raw answers?

You should be able to see exactly what each AI tool said, query by query, as screenshots or copied text with dates. A summary score with no evidence behind it can't be checked, and you'll have nothing to compare against in 3 months. More on this in what to ask before you trust an AI ranking report.

04How do you handle answers that change from run to run?

AI answers vary by design. Ask how many times they run each query and how often they recheck. Good agencies log every result, including the repeat "no" results, and report the trend.

05What do you measure, and what counts as good?

Look for these:

For citation rate, my working benchmarks are 10 to 20% for a business new to this, 30 to 50% for moderate, and 50% or more for strong. If an agency reports only keyword rankings, or one "AI score" it can't explain, keep asking. Here are the 7 metrics I use.

06Do you check whether AI gets my facts right?

Being mentioned with the wrong hours, the wrong prices or a service you dropped 2 years ago can cost you more than not being mentioned at all. A good audit checks branded answers claim by claim against your real website and flags every error.

07What do you check outside my website?

AI tools pull from Google reviews, directories, local publications, Reddit threads and industry listings. Ask whether the audit looks at where your customers spend time online and whether you show up there.

08What happens after the audit?

The audit should end with fixes ranked by urgency, the biggest problem first. Ask who does the work, how long each fix takes, and when they'll rerun the same queries. Get the starting point in writing before anything gets touched. Without it, nobody can prove what changed.

AEO agency red flags and good signs

What you hearRed flagGood sign
Proof"Every business is different"A named client with dated AI answers and analytics
Queries"We check your brand name"A written list of buyer questions for your service and area
PlatformsOne AI toolChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, Perplexity
EvidenceA score with no detailRaw answers you can see and save
TestingOne run, one reportRepeat runs and a trend over weeks
MetricsKeyword rankings onlyCitation rate, accuracy, share of voice, AI referral traffic
Promises"Guaranteed #1 in ChatGPT"A starting point, a target and a recheck date

Nobody can guarantee a spot in an AI answer. The platforms don't sell placement, and their answers change daily. Walk away from any agency that guarantees one.

How to run a quick AI visibility check yourself

You can get a rough starting point in about 30 minutes.

  1. Write down 10 questions a new customer would ask before hiring you. Include your service and your city.
  2. Ask each question in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, then search it on Google to see the AI Overview.
  3. Note whether you appear, which page gets cited, and which competitors show up instead.
  4. Ask each tool "What is [your business name] and what do they do?" Check every claim against your website.
  5. Save everything with the date.
  6. Repeat in 2 weeks and compare.

Bring that sheet to any agency call. A good agency will want to see it. If you'd rather have me run it, start with the Four Questions.

Summary

Want to run these questions on me? Here's exactly how Answer Visible works as an AEO agency, including pricing and what I report on.

Sources: Answer Visible, Sapia's Barbershop case study, GA4 data May 1 to October 31, 2026, and dated AI answer checks September 10 to October 8, 2026.

Common questions.

What should I look for when evaluating an AEO agency?

Start with proof. Ask for a real client with dated AI answers from before and after the work, plus analytics showing what changed. Then ask which buyer questions they test, on which AI platforms, how often they rerun them, and whether you can see the raw answers.

What does real proof of AEO results look like?

Four things: a starting point showing what AI tools said before the work, dated AI answers after the work with the page that got cited, business numbers from analytics such as AI visits and bookings, and a named business whose website you can check yourself.

Which AI platforms should an AI visibility audit cover?

At minimum ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Perplexity. Each pulls from different sources, so a business can show up on one and be missing on another. An audit that checks one platform only tells you about that platform.

What is a good AI citation rate?

For the share of real customer questions where an AI tool names you, 10 to 20% is a typical starting point, 30 to 50% is solid, and 50% or more is strong. Measure it per question and per AI tool, over repeated runs.

Can an agency guarantee my business will show up in ChatGPT?

No. AI platforms don't sell placement, and their answers change from run to run. An agency can improve the odds by fixing your site, content and listings, then show you dated results. Treat any guarantee as a reason to keep looking.

Want to see the proof before you decide?

I'll walk you through real client results, show you the raw AI answers, and tell you plainly what I'd fix first on your site. Based in St. Petersburg, FL, working with businesses across Tampa Bay and nationally.

Stay ahead of the curve.

When I publish new research or find something that's working in AI search, I'll send it your way. Only when I have something worth your time. Promise I won't spam you, I'm too busy testing this stuff myself.

You're in. Talk soon.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.